Timeless Reality
Prabha Shah

Small Businesses Not Seeing Impact of Stimulus Package

As a cynic, I view Obama’s Stimulus Package more as a mounting future debt, then as an immediate fix for a struggling economy. Although there is a lot of good in the package, namely Democrats taking advantage of a rare consolidation of political power and fixing the crumbling infrastructure that has been ignored for decades, the wealth generating prospects seem a little dim.

If you view large construction projects as a way to get people working again and as vital to maintaining small companies around the country, there is a slight problem. There are very few “little guys” who can actually benefit from taking on massive reconstruction projects. For example, who is capable of fixing a county’s sewer lines or rebuilding the support framework of a bridge? The guy down the road or a huge corporate construction beast?

This situation is eerily reminscent of the reconstruction being done (or recently attempted) in Iraq. Obviously, taking on projects of such mass volume are left only to the huge firms capable of handling such a job. Unfortunately, the prospects of the stimulus package could result in yet another case of the rich getting richer.

And speaking of volume…and huge…

Nation Buys Porn With Stimulus Package

Much like the people who cashed last year’s stimulus check and then flooded Wal-Mart looking for a new TV, the new stimulus is generating more wealth for people who don’t need it in the first place. And seriously, how has “Stimulus Package” not been associated with a porn title yet? I could totally see the porn star who portrays Sarah Palin involved. Get to work on this, California.

And more volume…

GM Not the Only Struggling Car Maker

If only India had their own version of Obama. I thought Tata Motors was supposed to be strong. Aren’t they supposed to be building more fuel efficient cars? Either the need to burn fuel is ingrained in our human psyches, or maybe size does matter when it comes to cars.

Double entendres…can’t get enough.

Sunday Roundup: Falling for the Same Joke Edition

Terry’s Talkin

Great stuff from every Browns fan’s favorite mythical uncle, Terry Pluto. I’ve been reading Pluto for years and unlike a lot of other aging print sportswriters, he has demonstrated a wonderful humility in presenting his material. Pluto’s even-handed approach, genuine appreciation for the game and wonderful sense of history brings a much needed balance to the often cynical beast that is the Cleveland sports media.

Reading Pluto on a Sunday morning is a true highlight, especially in the dark days of July. His take, which is hopefully the last one, on Donte Stallworth strays from being overly judgmental (we get it – Stallworth is a bum and/or has some bad luck), and focuses on bad decisions of another sort – i.e., the Browns’ rationale for signing and then retaining the enigmatic wideout.

What the Browns can learn from the Donte Stallworth mess…

1. When Donte Stallworth was signed in the spring of 2008, they were desperate to add a veteran receiver. Joe Jurevicius had informed the team that his knee was becoming a problem, and he was not sure if he could start. The roster for receivers suddenly looked thin with Braylon Edwards, then a dropoff to the likes of Syndric Steptoe. They had traded their top three draft choices in 2008 for deals involving Brady Quinn, Corey Williams and Shaun Rogers.

I think both fans and the Phil Savage-led front office were still basking in the glow of the surprise 2007 offensive outbreak before it became apparant that much like in 2009, the Browns’ receiver corps were dangerously thin. Although when the Stallworth signing was announced, the popular sentiment was that this was a move that was going to push the Browns over the top. And most of us bought it. Think of the possibilities that were going through your mind this time last year. Braylon and Donte stretching the defense on the outside, K2 and JJ down the middle. Syndric not playing….

3. When the Browns were considering Stallworth in the spring of 2008, they knew the following: a) He had been on three different teams in the previous three years; b) There were media reports that he was in the NFL substance abuse program; c) While he had appeared in all 16 games in three of the previous four seasons, he was known as somewhat fragile, prone to pulled leg muscles; and d) He was the 13th pick in the 2002 draft, and had not lived up to his potential.

It seems Savage was blinded by his desire to win now, based on the 2007 near playoff results. Although I can never fault Savage for wanting to win, and based on his maverick trading record with the organization, it is apparant that he gave a great effort, the Stallworth signing is representative of his narrow-mindedness when it came to building a team for the future.

Of course, the Browns were not the only team who fell for Stallworth, or more correctly, his greatest asset….blinding speed. Much like teams fall in love with a quarterback’s arm strength while ignoring more important intangibles (sound familar?), Savage essentially had Al Davis-esque visions of DA throwing 60 yard bombs to Stallworth. Of course, one pulled muscle later, and those dreams were extinguished.

5. It’s hard to know exactly what other teams were bidding for Stallworth, but it seems the Browns at some point were bidding against themselves. For a guy in the NFL substance abuse program who has looking for a new team — again — they wrote a check for $4.5 million as a signing bonus. They guaranteed him $10 million on a contract announced as $35 million over seven years. The Browns’ deal is not one to keep a player with a questionable attitude motivated.

There was one team who was certainly not in the bidding….the Patriots. Although Stallworth blossomed in the Patriots’ historic offense of 2007, much of his success was due to New England’s incredibly deep set of weapons surrounding him. Plugging Stallworth into a system with Randy Moss and Wes Welker helped to inflate his value heading into free agency. Putting Stallworth with Braylon Edwards and not much else brought him back to reality.

6. When the front office and coaching staff was relieved after the 2008 season, the new regime faced their own decision on Stallworth. He was due a $4.5 million roster bonus on March 13. They didn’t like Stallworth as a player (too soft and injury prone), and they also had doubts about his character. Stallworth caught only 17 passes in 11 games in 2008, averaging 10.0 yards per catch. Even when healthy, he showed little reason to keep him around. But the new regime also was desperate for receivers, and decided to pay him the $4.5 million bonus. They also feared cap problems, because even if they cut Stallworth, he still counted for $6.4 million on the salary cap.

Throwing out the unfortunate mess that Stallworth created for himself in March, this has to be considered one of the initial missteps of the new Mangini regime. The team was gutting some of Savage’s additions earlier in the year, and it seemed logical that Stallworth would be the next to go. However, based on the incredibly thin depth at the position, thanks to Savage and the injury situation of Jurevicius, Mangini couldn’t pull the trigger. Now, an indefinite suspension, two draft picks and two aging veterans later, the Browns find themselves almost where they started from.

8. Obviously, there was no way to know that Stallworth would end up in this type of legal trouble, suspended indefinitely by the league and destined to be cut by the Browns once they resolve some salary cap issues with this contract. But both regimes compromised by overpaying for underachieving player with character problems because they hoped to squeeze something out of him — and they thought they had no other alternatives.

I have to wonder if the Browns draft day moves would have looked different if Stallworth had not become entangled in such a tragic situation. While I’m confident that Mangini would have taken a wideout fairly high in the draft, I’m curious if he would have grabbed a second player, like he did with Mohammed Massaquoi. It is likely that a second wideout would have been taken, but the pick could have come much later in the draft.

If you buy into the theory that the lack of depth at wide receiver forced the Browns hand on two different occasions, first with his initial signing and then by paying him a roster bonus a few months ago, it is quite remarkable to think that a fairly marginal talent has helped to dictate the team’s direction. Going a step further, if the Browns’ draft day strategy was also affected by Stallworth’s tenuous status, one has to think that the presence of this player has created one of the most starcrossed situations in recent memory.

All this for a guy who runs fast.

A
nd in other news…speaking of more projections….

Browns Sign James Davis

The Browns have reported signed sixth-round pick RB James Davis (Clemson) to a four-year deal, according to Pro Football Talk.

Davis has made a favorable impression early on in his rookie season, leading one AFC North front office exec to proclaim that the Browns got a “steal” in drafting him in the sixth round. While Davis struggled in a weak Clemson offense in 2008, he was widely considered to be a first-day pick going into that season.

I have been skeptical of the hype surrounding James Davis for two reasons:

1. Browns fans tend to soar to hyperbolic heights regarding the potential of running backs. At different times in the past, Madre Hill was a unearthed gem, Ben Gay was the second coming, Lee Suggs was the new Leroy Kelly, William Green was a stable human being, Jerome Harrison is the new Leon Washington, and so it goes…the arrival of James Davis reaches similar parallels.

2. Davis is a 6th round draft pick.

However, considering the depth at the position, which has been largely untouched since the arrival of Jamal Lewis in 2007, it is possible that Davis can make the roster as a rookie, and could contribute in 2009. His only real competition seems to be special teams veteran Noah Herron. As for his future with the team, signing a four-year contract seems to suggest that he has indeed shown some promise during the offseason.

And on an unrelated note…something that struck me as funny….

Donte Whitner Doesn’t Like Pro Football Talk.com

I learned while perusing Twitter that Bills safety Donte Whitner isn’t happy with us.

Let’s see if he rectifies his error.

I’ve always admired the play of Donte Whitner and his recent tweet (I feel so dirty) blasting PFT.com further elevates his worth in my eyes. While I greatly enjoy the gonzo-rumor mongering tendencies of PFT.com, even they have to admit that they are not exactly a beacon of sports journalism.

One of PFT.com’s strategies in “breaking news” is to suggest that something is going to happen (a.k.a., throw it against the wall…), then if it sticks, great. If not, oh well. This strategy can be effective, but PFT’s success rate is eerily similar to a weak hitting shortstop’s batting average.

As for Whitner “rectifying” the situation, perhaps PFT should take the initial step and add a “rumor clarification” section to their fancy new NBC website. This way, no one’s feelings will be hurt.

Monument
Jenny Holzer

Big Fan
When I first heard that Patton Oswalt was playing the role of an obsessed football fan in the upcoming Big Fan, I was giddy. Like many other fans of authentic stand-up comedy, I could only envision what the greatest savant of American nerd culture would bring to the most underserved of cinema subjects. Oswalt’s comedy topics are completely original and delivered with the resentful troll-like sentimentality of an angry kid easily diverted by Cheetos and comics.

However, the newly released trailer for Big Fan shows a darker side of Oswalt, one that has not fully adjusted to reality. The scene where Oswalt is rehearsing his “script” for a sports talk radio show highlights the depths of this character’s isolation. This film will probably disappoint some hardcore Patton fans, but it looks remarkably original. Bonus points for the inclusion of great character actor Kevin Corrigan.

[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-i42Mrw3no&hl=en&fs=1&]

And although I’m slowly moving away from sports, this is a tragic story that will largely go unnoticed in the mainstream media….because of UFC’s 100th show and the fact that Michael Jackson, despite being fully dead, will not go away.

Arturo Gatti Found Dead

As most boxing fans already know, Gatti’s trilogy with Micky Ward were among the most brutal and frenetic fights in the recent history of the sport. The fights essentially ended Micky Ward’s career and did some serious damage to Gatti. The entire career of Gatti proved that he is the rarest of modern atheletes, one who truly gave every part of himself to his sport. If there ever was a real life Rocky, at least in terms of the abuse his body and mind suffered because of the way he fought, it was Gatti.

[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vKObKLdiSPg&hl=en&fs=1&]

You know it’s bad when both Obama and Chavez call a country out.

Honduras Coup Spotlights Latin America’s Growing Instability

And finally, I always thought Ben Franklin was more of a player. This is kind of disappointing.

Ben Franklin Was a Badass (Indeed)

Reboot 2009 Fantasy Football Preview

As a somewhat functioning member of the Cleveland sports blogosphere, Cleveland Reboot serves its reading public by offering analysis and commentary, providing day old news and references and hopefully sharing a mocking laugh that attempts to strangle the pretentiousness in all of us who have a voice regarding the teams and community we care about. With such a wealth of information and opinion found online regarding the Browns and the NFL in general, we realize that it is hard to find the information and commentary you are seeking, especially when it comes to such pressing questions as:

1. Will Eric Mangini finally restore the Browns to their once great heights of success?

5. Is Peyton Manning or Tom Brady the better choice for my fantasy football team?

Considering the struggles the Browns are likely to face in 2009, based on another regime change and a roster in transition, the last question is more reflective of many Browns’ fans desire to divert their attention in 2009 to the realm of fantasy. Much like the idea of the Browns’ defense becoming an aggressive, vicious, attacking unit in 2009, perhaps the hopes of fans of our great organization are better placed in a world based solely on make believe.

So, in the spirit of community awareness and mindless speculation, and as a public service to all the readers of the site, Cleveland Reboot proudly offers its 2009 Fantasy Football Preview. Consider this as your ultimate source for fantasy football.

EDITOR’S NOTE -
The staff of Cleveland Reboot thinks fantasy football is a complete waste of time and inflates the value of players based on often meaningless statistics. Although initially designed for fun and as a way to enhance the game experience, fantasy football cheapens the sport and most of its’ participants become dumber in the process.

Anyway, you’ve sent questions and we have answers.

Reboot,
I have the first pick in my fantasy league. It’s me, my cousin Rick and two guys I work with. Who should I take?
-J.R., Solon

J.R.,
Ummm…I don’t know, your cousin? In building a quality team, you should start with the basics. How about an offensive tackle? I like Walter Jones, but he’s starting to age. How about Joe Thomas or Ryan Clady? Oh wait, left tackles don’t have any stats in fantasy football? Oh…well, screw you.

Reboot,
Should I take Adrian Peterson in the first round, or wait for a player like Matt Forte in the later rounds?
-Matt, Geneva

Matt,
I’m pretty sure Peterson and Forte have already been drafted. (I had no idea how uninformed these readers were.)

Reboot,
Does L.T. have anything left in the tank? He’s been a touchdown machine before, but I’m worried about taking him high.
-Jason, Frankfort

Jason,
Based on his recent past, it appears L.T. breaks down heading into the playoffs. Wait…you say that your fantasy season ends in December? Oh, well who cares then?

Reboot,
Is Peyton Manning the greatest fantasy quarterback ever?
-Tommy, Oak Grove

Tommy,
Manning is pretty good in reality, too. But, then again, I guess it depends on what kind of fantasy you had in mind.

Reboot,
Who in Dallas loses the most now that Terrell Owens has gone to Buffalo?
-Alex, Central Station

Alex,
Probably fantasy nerds like you, who base a player’s value solely on stats.

Reboot,
Is Jay Cutler worth drafting as quarterback of the Bears?
-Dennis, Springfield

Dennis,
I’m thinking it was worth it for the Bears to trade for him…you know, in reality.

Reboot,
Who is the first Browns player that should be taken in my upcoming fantasy draft?
-Rick, Parma

Rick,
I think the selection of Joe Thomas would be a good start. However, if we’re dealing in fantasy, I would grab David Veikune. To think that he will smoothly transition to the NFL and contribute in his first year is pure fantasy.

Reboot,
Who is primed for a big bounce-back year?
-Janice, Bloomfield

Janice,
It was reported that Isaac Sowells fell the other day in his basement. That could be something worth looking into.

Reboot,
Who is a safer pick: Tom Brady or Matt Cassell?
-Buddy, New Haven

Buddy,
A safer pick to do what? Play quarterback in the NFL? Do you even watch football?

Reboot,
In my keeper league, I hold the rights to Brett Favre, but I’m concerned about his prospects in going to Minnesota. What should I do?
-Peter, Connecticut

Peter,
What the hell are you talking about? Are you Favre’s agent or something?

Reboot,
Which team’s players will benefit most from an easy schedule?
-Barbershop, Elyria

Barbershop,
Wouldn’t the teams be the ones who benefit from an easy schedule?

Reboot,
One guy in my FFL is such a dick. He took Roddy White and Randy Moss, then traded them both. Isn’t that a total dick move?
-Taylor, Kappa Kappa Delta

Taylor,
Total dick move, indeed. Now, stop hugging that guy.

Reboot,
Any tips on sleeper picks in 2009?
-Carlos, Mansfield

Carlos,
I hear Derek Anderson is a fan of the occasional power nap.

Reboot,
I am torn and I need help. I really want to take Brandon Marshall, but I’m worried about his contract situation and off the field issues. Help!
-Teddy, Omaha

Teddy,
Calm down, kid. Perhaps you should consider joining a Fantasy Malcontent League. In such an environment, I would trade up to grab Marshall. Is Plaxico still in the league? Take him, too.

Reboot,
What veteran has flown under the radar and could be a good value pick?
-M
ason, Columbia

Mason,
I can list dozens of quality veterans around the league, but unfortunately, they’re all linemen and it’s doubtful you have heard of them.

Reboot,
Who is the best pick for a backup quarterback?
-Glenn, Cincinnati

Glenn,
The one who doesn’t have to play.

Reboot,
I have serious concerns about Brett Favre going to Minnesota. I’m worried that his legacy will be tarnished.
-Peter, Connecticut

Peter,
Although it’s a Favre question, this is one that is somewhat football related. Wait a minute, is this Peter King? Oh, grow up.

Reboot,
Who is the best long-shot wide receiver?
-Syndric, Berea

Syndric,
Considering the Browns’ depth at WR this year, this is your time to shine.

Reboot,
Stop stealing my stuff. The mailbag is the only thing I have left.
-Tony G., Cleveland

Tony,
You are the best and you inspire me everyday.

Well, I hope that helped. If your question was not answered, feel free to email Cleveland Reboot here .

Check back next April for Cleveland Reboot’s 2010 Mock Draft and as always, good luck with your teams in 2009. Oh, and if you get the opportunity, try actually watching an entire NFL game this year, instead of just the highlights.

Scoundrels, Malcontents and Roustabouts

Wednesday’s piece on Braylon Edwards generated a lot of great buzz within the marble-walled palace of Cleveland Reboot. In the piece, I was merely attempting to raise the possibility of what fan reaction could be towards Braylon, based on his limited role in the hours leading up to Donte Stallworth’s fateful accident, as well as the history between the Browns community and the mercurial wideout.

In keeping an eye on various Browns’ media outlets the past couple days, it doesn’t look like this story is gaining much traction. Reboot readers have largely defended Braylon’s actions, which is a natural reaction, considering that he is not legally linked or otherwise responsible for what happened a few months ago. Around the Internet, this story has been somewhat quiet, which is certainly a relief for Braylon. The last thing our delicate flower of a superstar needs is more negativity heading into 2009.

And speaking of wide receivers and negativity…

Stallworth Released From Jail

Well, that was fast.

Let’s be honest. Who even knew that Stallworth was serving jail time?

Browns receiver Donte’ Stallworth has been released from a Miami jail after serving a 24-day jail term.

But while the worst of the consequences have ended for Stallworth, he will be placed on Florida’s version of house arrest for two years.

Of course, I remember that Stallworth was sentenced, basically as a formality after agreeing to pay a vast financial settlement to the family of the victim, but his release from prison still delivers an odd, almost surreal sense of injustice. However, in viewing the collapse of several state governments across the country, releasing a non-threatening inmate is a reflection of the times. If you’re a petty criminal or an irresponsible, rich athlete, life is good right now.

He also will eventually have a meeting with NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell, who has indefinitely suspended Stallworth.

Eventually, Stallworth will received a firm suspension from the league. In the late 1990s, Rams defensive end Leonard Little was suspended eight games for similar conduct. Though we think that Goodell’s enhanced focus on imposing punishment for off-field behavior means that Stallworth likely will be sidelined for a full year, there’s a chance that Goodell will decide not to allow Stallworth or any other NFL player to participate in the supposed privilege of playing pro football while on house arrest.

Considering his reputation for discipline and disdain for athletes who tarnish the image of the NFL, a meeting with Roger Goodell has to scare even the most hardened of players. Like many in the media world have already suggested, the easy part is over for Stallworth. Now, he will receive his real sentence.

Of course, all of this speculation tends to diminish the guilt that Stallworth is probably feeling based on his actions. As a human being, Stallworth must be experiencing some real trauma, albeit mixed with vast relief that this whole situation could have ended much worse than it did. If anyone ever needed a smoke, it’s Donte.

Of course, the commissioner awaits.

And speaking of waiting…or at least bad timing (on many different levels)…

Phil Dawson’s Status

Prediction based on what I’m hearing: Phil Dawson will not kick for Cleveland this season. He wants a new contract and there’s a standoff.

I realize this is old news, but it still fascinates me that Dawson would pick this year as his time to get paid. As solid as Dawson has been on the field for the Browns over the past decade, the longest-tenured Brown is not exactly a savant when it comes to calling his shots regarding his checkbook.

The arrival of a no-nonsense organizational leader in Eric Mangini and a resulting wealth of personnel turnover is a toxic environment for Dawson to acheive his goal of winning a new contract. Although the new offense should feature more ball control and stress field position, ideal in raising Dawson’s value, it is unlikely that Mangini will cave in to a kicker’s contract demands – especially when the new coach is trying to establish his own law throughout Berea.

It is unfortunate to speculate on this, but the reality is that Dawson will not be a member of the Browns going forward, unless he relents in his demands. While Dawson has been an important member of the team, his position is one that is easily replaceable. Already, rookie Parker Douglass has worked with the team and it is likely that additional kickers will be brought to training camp to compete for the job. And no doubt Douglass has the immense support of the entire South Dakota State University football community.

[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xe1jv3euexA&hl=en&fs=1&]

What is it with the Browns special teams this offseason? Perhaps the unit has been inspired by the political unrest around the world. First, Josh Cribbs attempts his ode to a Honduran coup by threatening to no show OTA’s, and now Dawson shows his revolutionary roots. Now, I’m worried that Ryan Pontbriand will refuse to snap the ball come late July. Viva Zapata, indeed.

And for some lighter news…

Rookie Davis Can’t Wait

Davis ran hot and cold at Clemson.

It appears his ego can take a punch. He was one of the surprise players in the minicamp that laid the groundwork for next month’s training camp. Head Coach Eric Mangini said he was “extremely pleased” with Davis all the way around.

r />

The arrival of James Davis signals the long-held hopes that Browns fans cling to regarding running backs. Call it the Curse of Jim Brown, but our great franchise has struggle to produce top-flight backs over the past several decades. After the great success of Byner and Mack in the 80’s, the Browns suffered a long drought until the likes of Reuben Droughns and Jamal Lewis broke through in recent years.

The cynical side of me sees James Davis as another entry in the Browns Last Supper of Running Back Potential, which includes the likes of Lee Suggs, William Green and Jerome Harrison. However, much like Harrison, Davis can take advantage of the weak depth at running back in 2009 to hopefully establish himself as a piece for the Browns’ future under Mangini.

However, if Davis is going to make it in Cleveland, it is likely that he will have to help shore up the special teams units. Not an easy task for a player who ran with the first and second teams in college. Also, the Browns added Noah Herron in the offseason, whose primary role on the roster could be as a special teams contributor.

“I think the main thing Mangini is looking for is consistency,” Davis said matter of factly. “That’s what I try to bring to the field every day.”

“I’ve got keep that in my head,” he said.

And while I’ve been viewed as cynical in the past, I think we all need to “keep in our heads” the fact that we’re talking about a 6th Round Draft pick. Excitement in Cleveland regarding running backs tends to border on the idealistic extremes…witness the Curious Case of Madre Hill. However, if Davis can break through during training camp, it is possible that he could stick around long enough to get an opportunity.

And unlike Stallworth and Dawson, at least Davis will actually be at training camp.

Thursday Roundup: Potential and Breakouts Edition

As the long weeks leading up to training camp slowly begin to dissipate, and much like the legitimacy of a Phil Dawson holdout, prognosticators are beginning to unsheathe their sharp knives, readying for the possible realities that lie ahead. Or, in other words, the suspense is killing me….what is this team going to look like in 2009?

On the surface, the Browns are entering another regime change and have questions at almost every position among the roster. Although the arrival of Eric Mangini signals that this often directionless franchise headquartered in Berea finally has some much-needed order and stability; it is impossible to predict what kind of success the team will experience in 2009.

The most ideal scenario for the Browns would parallel Mangini’s initial success with the Jets in 2006, when the littlest version of Bill Parcells led his team to a surprise playoff appearance. Mangini brought a change in culture to New York, replacing the more cuddly Herman Edwards and installing more accountability to the Jet franchise. Let’s hope that Mangini can have similar success in Cleveland, as he replaces the loveable Uncle Romeo and puts his own unique and pesky stamp on the Browns.

As is often the case in sports and life, success will ultimately be determined by the level of talent on the field. For the Browns in 2009, there is a strange pot brewing, as the untested will be lumped into a framework of battle-tested veterans, along with a diminishing base of core players. The on-field result is impossible to predict, especially during the second week of July, but in the meantime, one lingering question will remain heading into training camp and beyond…who will emerge in 2009 as a key player as we dive into yet anoter new chapter of rebirth?

AFC North’s Breakout Players

In a division filled with quality defenses, it was only fitting that a young, up-and-coming linebacker caught the most attention of his AFC North peers.

In the closest vote of the entire player survey, Cincinnati Bengals second-year linebacker Keith Rivers edged linebacker Lawrence Timmons of the Pittsburgh Steelers and Cleveland Browns quarterback Brady Quinn by one vote to become the 2009 pick for breakout player.

Not to belittle Brady Quinn, but obviously if he wins the starting QB job in Cleveland, he is destined for a breakout year, merely based on the volume of playing time he will receive. Production aside, Quinn’s 2009 season could be evaluated more in terms of survival and avoiding disaster, rather than by completion percentage or yardage.

As I have stated before, Quinn is essentially auditioning to be the QB not just in 2009, but for the remainder of Eric Mangini’s tenure in Cleveland. Unfortunately for Quinn, the talent surrounding him on offense will make this extended interview a difficult environment to succeed in.

AFC North Breakout Player
As voted by 32 anonymous players in the division:
Player Pos. Team Votes

1. Keith Rivers LB Bengals 6
(Tie) 2. Lawrence Timmons LB Steelers 5
Brady Quinn QB Browns 5
4. Brian Robiskie WR Browns 3
(Tie) 5. D’Qwell Jackson LB Browns 2
Chris Henry WR Bengals 2
Joe Flacco QB Ravens 2
(tie) 8. Cedric Benson RB Bengals 1
Limas Sweed WR Steelers 1
Eric Wright CB Browns 1
Rey Maualuga LB Bengals 1
Carey Davis FB Steelers 1
Santonio Holmes WR Steelers 1
Syndric Steptoe WR Browns 1
* Note: Players surveyed could not vote for themselves or teammates.

I think the same case could be made for rookie wideout Brian Robiskie. Although historically, rookie wide receivers not named Randy Moss tend to struggle in their introduction to the NFL, Robiskie will benefit from the alarmingly thin depth at the position in Cleveland. Much like Quinn will benefit from merely getting snaps, it is not a stretch to suggest that Robiskie could contribute 30-40 catches to the offense in 2009.

Said one future opponent of the rookie Robiskie: “He’s a polished receiver and his dad [Terry] being a coach will help his learning process.”

Again, it’s a stretch to suggest that a rookie receiver is already “polished.” Robiskie still has a steep learning curve, although the popular sentiment is that his pedigree should help him succeed. Let’s hope so.

If not Robiskie, then who?

Oh right, Syndric Steptoe. Really? Syndric? An “anonymous” player voted for Syndric? I’m guessing Syndric ran under the Libertarian party. Or perhaps Bruce Gradkowski was polled before he signed on with Oakland? Either way, one of the wonderful freedoms we have in this great democracy is the right to waste your vote.

Getting back to the traditional two-party system…the names of Eric Wright and D’Quell Jackson as breakout players are encouraging signs for a defense that will likely have to carry the team in 2009. Although I view both players as complimentary to the defense, meaning that they will blossom only when better talent surrounds them, I am still encouraged that both could progress under new defensive leadership.

Although Eric Barton is merely a one-year fix at inside linebacker, he is probably an upgrade over Andra Davis. This move alone could help Jackson to improve on his already impressive tackle totals of the past two seasons. Much like other smaller and athletic linebackers, Jackson needs a bullish ILB partner who can take on blocks and allow him to roam the field. Hopefully, Barton can provide these services in 2009, before better quality help is added in the coming seasons.

As for Wright, he does not have much help around him. As it stands now, Wright is the most talented of the Browns’ defensive backs and will be counted on to guard the opposing team’s best receiver. As much as I love Wright’s instincts and determination, I do not see him becoming a true #1 corner. Much like Jackson, the best hope for Wright developing into a premier player lies in the addition of a worthy partner at cornerback.

And in speaking of the defense….

Most of the initial reports regarding the arrival of new defensive coordinator Rob Ryan have been complimentary. There seems to be a wealth of excitement being generated regarding the potential of the Browns defense, which could be generously characterized as “long suffering.”

But then again, we are still dwelling in July potential and idealism. The OBR’s Rich Passan offers a more realistic slant.

Rich Passan’s Take on the Browns Defense

News: New Browns defensive coordinator Rob Ryan promises the Browns will stop the ru
n this season. “My whole life I’ve stopped the run and you can look that up,” he told the media. “We’ll get it done here.”

Views: Well, we looked it up and we didn’t like what we saw. At least during the last five seasons.

In those five seasons with Oakland (2004-2008), the Raiders’ defense ranked 22nd, 25th, 25th, 31st and 31st, respectively, against the run in the 32-team National Football League. The Browns, meanwhile, ranked 32nd, 25th, 25th, 27th and 28th. The Raiders permitted 138.7 yards a game in that span. The Browns yielded 141.6 a contest.

If that’s stopping the run, let’s redefine the term.

Well, that’s depressing. Even for a realist like myself.

Certainly, Ryan seems to be an upgrade over Todd Grantham and Mel Tucker. While Grantham brought some good energy to the position and Tucker worked wonders with the secondary before 2008, Ryan has more NFL experience and offers a familiarity with different schemes that should benefit the defense in 2009. Although much like the offense, Ryan doesn’t have a whole lot to work with.

However, the presence of Shaun Rogers is a good starting point. While the defense beyond Rogers is not exactly inspiring, the defensive line rotation could be surprisingly deep, with the arrivals of Kenyon Coleman and C.J. Mosley, along with the return of Robaire Smith. Eric Barton could help out in the run defense, as his primary role could be take on second level blockers, freeing up the likes of Jackson to make tackles.

The wild card in terms of stuffing the run could be the play of Abe Elam at safety. While Elam is not a great pass defender, he is an upgrade in terms of run support over the departed Sean Jones. Playing Elam closer to the line on running downs could bring a slight upgrade to a run defense that has proven to cause immense frustration for Browns fans.

While a dramatic improvement in the run defense is still a lofty goal for the Browns, it is very possible that Ryan will slightly upgrade the team’s biggest weakness in 2009. The first challenge is changing the defenders’ mentality regarding defense. For any improvement to happen, the Browns’ identity on defense has to change towards a more aggressive style and mindset, which Ryan seems eager to help deliver.

Again, much like several other areas on the roster…it’s a work in progress.

Speaking of which…

2005 Draft Contracts

The agents for Merriman, Edwards and White are among several who have expressed interest in doing long-term contracts, but have gotten little response from teams.

Everyone in Cleveland knows the story of Braylon Edwards…tremendously talented, physically gifted, son of a former NFL athlete, emotionally insecure, possible accomplice…basically, the organization and fans have no earthly idea what they’re going to get out of Braylon, other than intrigue.

And considering recent information regarding Braylon, his financial future could be another mystery. So, Browns fans have yet another mystery to unravel in trying to figure out everyone’s favorite Lakefront enigma.

However, despite some of these qualities, the Browns could have done a lot worse in the 2005 draft. Considering their position at the top of the draft, Phil Savage could have missed badly. Looking at the names surrounding Edwards, it turns out (as it often does) that 2005 was not the year to draft a running back, which is always a possibility in Cleveland.

Hindsight being what it is, the Browns could have grabbed either Shawne Merriman or DeMarcus Ware much later in the round, or taken the safer pick with Logan Mankins. And of course, potential being what it is, would you rather have Braylon or one of the true 3-4 pass rushing OLB’s on the roster now?

Unlike most of the other questions being asked now, this one may have a more definitive answer.

Let It Loose

Well, this could end badly.

According to a recorded interview with Miami Beach police, Donte Stallworth spent the early hours of March 14 partying with fellow teammate Braylon Edwards, among others, before killing a pedestrian later in the morning. Obviously, Edwards was not involved in the fatal crash and does not share any responsibility for what happened to an unlucky Florida pedestrian…which unfortunately is strikingly similar to Stallworth’s pedestrian criminal sentence, thanks to money and a backwards system of Florida law.

Stallworth’s Interview with Police

However, in the sometimes more just court of public opinion, the details that have emerged regarding Braylon’s involvement with Stallworth in the hours leading up to the accident will likely draw the wrath and scorn of most Browns fans. The friction between Braylon and the Cleveland community, which was highlighted by the star wideout’s inconsistent play in 2008, could explode after this story makes the rounds in various Cleveland media outlets. Of course, Braylon probably still thinks the fans dislike him primarily for his Michigan roots.

In a recorded interview with police, Stallworth said he met fellow Browns receiver Braylon Edwards and others at a hotel sometime after 2 a.m. on March 14. Stallworth said he drank some tequila from Edwards’ table and later bought some shots himself.

Lab tests later showed Stallworth had a blood-alcohol level of .126, above Florida’s .08 limit.

Before continuing, I have to state that I despise moralistic sentiments when it comes to analyzing the private lives of athletes and public figures, so it’s pointless to judge Braylon. However, it is worth noting, or at least to wonder, whether some Browns fans and those outside the realm of Cleveland sports, will try to link Stallworth’s actions with Braylon, or hold him responsible for what ultimately happened. Let me go on the bloggy record and state that any future commentary regarding Braylon’s actions will serve as more of a reflection of his character, rather than expose any legal entanglements.

Edwards, 26, said he and Stallworth had drinks earlier in the day by the pool at the hotel before meeting at the nightclub. A receipt shows that Edwards spent $3,443 that night at the club — including $1,500 on Perrier-Jouet Rose champagne and $695 on Grey Goose vodka — and he said Stallworth didn’t seem impaired when they parted ways early the morning of the crash. Edwards had a room at the hotel.

In a completely unrelated note, I’m pretty sure I could buy some of the dives I frequent when visiting the devil’s playground of Akron for the amount Braylon spent on drinks. God bless you, Braylon. More importantly, for the sake of defending Braylon, the article notes that unlike Stallworth, he safely deposited himself in a hotel room after the party was over.

“We’re friends. If he were anything outside himself, I would have told him to stay here. He looked OK. He looked fine,” Edwards said in a recorded statement.

Stallworth’s credit card receipts shows he bought a $375 bottle of Patron Silver that he sent to Edwards’ table, five shots of the tequila for $90, a water and a Red Bull energy drink. Stallworth said some of the shots were for female friends.

However, it will be interesting to see what the reaction is regarding Braylon’s statement. Unfortunately, I sense a backlash that could mount against Braylon, as some readers may interpret his statement as not being responsible regarding the condition of Stallworth, and the consequences that resulted.

Finally, I find the Red Bull purchase highly entertaining. As many readers of Cleveland Reboot have pointed out in the past weeks, Braylon’s 2008 history of dropped passes could be a direct result of getting the shakes from chugging a pre-game Five Hour Energy. For Browns fans who support this theory, it looks you are in for another long season. And for Braylon’s sake, let’s hope he isn’t about to lose an endorsement deal.

The toxicology analysis also confirms reports that Stallworth tested positive for marijuana in addition to alcohol. Neither Stallworth nor Edwards mentioned any use of marijuana.

This could be the kicker in terms of further speculation. Again, the actions of Stallworth cannot be linked to Braylon, but suspicion will likely remain. Also, if this story develops, it is possible that the John Wayne of the NFL, Roger Goodell, could take a deeper look, which could mean some increased heat coming Braylon’s way.

Speaking of another look, here’s Pro Football Talk.com’s Gregg Rosenthal’s post.

Edwards Partied with Stallworth on Night of Accident

Braylon Edwards thought Donte’ Stallworth was fine. Otherwise, he would have stopped his friend from driving the morning of March 14, when Stallworth ultimately killed a pedestrian, Mario Reyes.

Edwards has had difficulties with his image and can’t be thrilled this news is becoming public just before a contract year. Stallworth, currently serving a 30-day jail sentence for DUI manslau
ghter, has far greater problems.

So far, Braylon has only been convicted of being filthy rich…and being unwilling to incriminate himself, according to PFT.com. Of course, as Rosenthal points out, Braylon’s future earning power could be hurt if this story further develops. For a player who already struggles with the mental and emotional aspects of the game, the presence of this story could further distract Braylon in 2009. And as most Browns fans are aware, the last thing Braylon needs are more distractions.

However, in the dead early weeks of July, this story and the subsequent opinions that will be delivered by fans could further tarnish Braylon’s image and his role on the team. The coming days should be very interesting.

Rebutting the Rebuttal: Broken Crayons Edition

The blindingly gorgeous prospects of an early July allow us all to parade around the bandwidths of public opinion, emerging as gridrion prophets and caretakers of the endless optimism that surrounds a sun-drenched Berea. For in July, it really doesn’t matter that the 2009 Browns are entering yet another first year of a new coaching regime, or that the current collection of talent on the roster appears to be riddled with questions and concerns worthy of volumes of elegant prose.

Because as it stands now, the Browns’ odds to compete for a Super Bowl Championship are as good as any other team in the league. Why not? If you allow yourself to embrace the Zen-like philosophy of “we shall see”, then every move made in Berea over the past six months is leading to a perfect destination…or not. Perhaps we should all embrace this feeling for as long as it continues to penetrate our hardened, Northeast Ohio sports fan shells.

But then again, what fun is that?

So, in the spirit of both debate and its sister contrarianism, as well as in a gesture of goodwill towards accurate, grammatical bliss, let us offer a counter argument to the sunshine streaming through the Internet in recent days. Or, perhaps in a more correct phrasing, allow me to retort.

Rebuttal to Reboot

I just want to start out and say I have read and always enjoyed the Cleveland Reboot blog. It’s a very intelligent and clever blog about the greatest franchise in football, The Cleveland Browns. I just believe that his recent post about our offense struggling this season to “find” an identity and whichever quarterback that starts not playing well needs a rebuttal.

First things first, thanks for the plug. I also enjoy the stylings of one Cleveland Reboot. And as for the objective of a rebuttal, I admit that I argue with myself constantly. Unflinchingly and stubbornly maintaining the same outlook is self-destructive. Debate is healthy.

Our offense will not struggle in 2009. They may not be top 5 or top 10, but we will score points. Let’s start with identity. The team has one…it is balanced. If you watched the Jets, and I have to tell you I watched many of their games because I am a Brett Farve fan, Leon Washington was used in the short passing game more than he was as a running back.

The Browns are installing a new offense, with a largely untested quarterback, an older featured running back, very few playmakers and a revamped offense line. However hopeful I am for the offense to acheive success in 2009, as a realist, I have to think that this unit will struggle in 2009. Having said this, I admit that the offense will gradually improve throughout the year, but this is a huge work in progress for the team moving forward.

As for an identity of being “balanced”, again, let’s wait and see. However, in viewing the current roster shortcomings, I’m not sure how this team will acheive this kind of benchmark. The only parallel we have now, other than player analysis, is to look at the 2008 Jets. The flaw in using that logic is that the Browns are not the 2008 Jets. Isolating the running back position, it is obvious that Jamal Lewis is not Thomas Jones and Jerome Harrison is not Leon Washington…in reality, these comparisons are not so easy.

Cleveland Reboot goes on to say the browns have “an aging featured running back in Jamal Lewis”. Jamal Lewis is younger than Thomas Jones and he can break tackles much more often. So if Jones can flourish in Mangini’s offense than so can Jamal. The Browns even have their very own Leon Washington…Jerome Harrison. We all complained about the lack of use we saw out of Harrison; well in 2009 prepare to see him used EXACTLY like Leon Washington. Expect to see his best this season.

Technically, Jamal Lewis is a half year younger than Thomas Jones, but in terms of NFL mileage, Jones is relatively fresh compared to the more experienced Lewis. Jones bounced around the league for 3-4 seasons, before contributing with Chicago a few seasons ago. Compare this with Lewis, who has been a workhorse back in the league since the 2000 season.

And as much as I would love to see Jerome Harrison finally break through in 2009, comparing him to Leon Washington is a bit of a stretch at the moment. As for seeing Harrison’s “best” in 2009…I would hope so, considering he hasn’t contributed much in the league so far in his career. I wouldn’t think he could get any worse.

Our wide receivers (even with the rookies) will be more prepared this year Week 1 than we ever saw them last year. These guys are all fighting for playing time. Our “one playmaker”, as Reboot refers to him, Braylon Edwards is in a contract year so he will be at the top of his game (which could be 80 Catches 1289 yds and 16 TDs). Last year we experienced so many injuries at WR. Joe Jurevicious, K2, Braylon, and Stallworth were all injured for a period of time. We are coming in with a very deep squad…

Having 10 wide receivers on the current roster does not necessarily equate to having depth. My main point in analyzing the current collection of receivers is that after Braylon, there is no dynamic player who can be relied upon to step up. Although I view Robiskie and Massaquoi as intriguing rookies, they are just that….rookies. With the exception of playing quarterback, rookie wide receivers historically have a very difficult time transitioning to the NFL.

“… the Browns offense is going to be pretty weak. Much like in the early days of the reborn franchise.” (exact quote from Reboot post). Wow, I thought my prediction of a top 15 defense is bold. Why would this offense struggle so bad? What is so wrong with this offense line? As many of you have read and commented on before our offensive line is in great shape. They possess pro-bowlers, veterans, youth, and size.

Again, the offense will rely on several untested players. As for the offensive line, I like the addition of Alex Mack, and Joe Thomas is solid at left tackle. While Eric Steinbach should give the Browns one more year of consistent play in 2009, the right side of the line has some question marks. Who are the starters at right guard and right tackle? Or, a better question could be: who are the starters when Ryan Tucker gets injured?

Whoever the quarterback may be this year, I do believe will have a good season…not to be confused with great though. In no way do I think the QB will continuously struggle. I think they ARE surrounded with enough talent to succeed. There are enough playmakers all over this offense to put up the points of 2007. We have seen greatness out of Jamal Lewis, Braylon Edwards, Joe Thomas, Josh Cribbs, and Derek Anderson (I’m still trying to find more articles about this “awkward throwing motion”)…all of which are still on this team and are all currently healthy. I think Brady Quinn has the talent to be great. I love the rookies we got in Mack, Robiskie, Massaquai, and
Davies.

The Browns have talent among the roster; the point to remember is that the team is again in the first year of a regime change. To expect success so quickly is a little misguided. And using a term like “Greatness” is an explosion of hyperbolic fancy, which does not accurately describe the blip of success the Browns experienced in 2007. And the last time “greatness” and Derek Anderson were found in the same room, DA was likely reminiscing about his afternoon nap.

While I don’t claim to be an NFL analyst steeped in the experience and knowledge of a long-time scout or coach, my eyes usually don’t deceive me. Derek Anderson holds the ball at an awkward angle and when he releases, his passes tend to sail on him. While this may be an admirable trait for a deep-ball passer, DA’s motion leads to inaccurate throws. Witness the Cincinnati game from late 2007.

PREDICTION: 23.8 pts/game..not bad…
~ The Optimist

If the Browns scored 23.8 points per game, that would place them 12th in the league, based on 2008 numbers. Not exactly scientific, but pretty convenient.

*hopefully I didn’t offend Cleveland Reboot in any way, again I recommend his page to anyone who loves the Browns. I love to debate football, especiallly the Browns so hopefully no offense was taken*

It takes a lot to offend someone who was long ago delivered into the world as a Browns fan. It’s not like anyone took the name of Webster Slaughter in vain. The only offense that myself or anyone else should take would result from continuing to not stray from a formulaic, simple and often destructive philosophy of commentary.

In this sense, debate should always be a permanent fixture in any variety of media, because without it, we all become merely receivers and cheerleaders. Without real debate and opinions, the wonderful gift of a public forum to authentically challenge the status quo and each other is wasted.

Can we do it?

We shall see.

As It Stands Again – Defensive Backs

The following is Part Seven of a series profiling the most essential positions that will determine success for the Browns in 2009. So far, the rankings have broken down like this:

1. Linebackers
2. Defensive Line
3. Wide Receivers
4. Offensive Line
5. Running Backs
6. Quarterbacks

The basis behind these rankings is as follows….First, the Browns’ most significant weakness since returning to the league in 1999 (besides inept front office management) has been the play of the defensive front seven. Until the Browns can solve their annually porous run defense and create some version of a pass rush, the team will continue to flounder.

The rest of the rankings reflect the absence of depth at key positions, as the current receiver and running back corps are amongst the worst in the franchise’s recent history. Receiver and running back are separated only by the offensive line, which although vitally important to the Browns’ success, seems to be stable heading into 2009.

The surprise among many readers is the ranking of the Browns’ quarterbacks as low on the list of positions that will determine success in 2009. Reboot has taken this stance purely to show that success at the quarterback position will largely be a result of the overall production generated by the rest of the offense.

Which leads us to the defensive backs…Much like the success of Brady Quinn or Derek Anderson will result from an improved offensive line, revamped running game and from the hopefully sticky hands of inconsistent receivers, the Browns’ secondary will benefit from increased production by the defensive front seven.

As It Stands Again – Defensive Backs

I am not stating that defensive backs are not essential to the overall play of the defense, but what goes on some ten to twenty yards in front of the secondary (or 30, in Romeo Crennel’s case) will either help to elevate the performance of Eric Wright, Abe Elam and company…or force them to play another frustrating year of soft zone defense.

Fortunately for the Browns, the arrival of Eric Mangini, who served as Bill Belichick’s defensive backs coach and Rob Ryan, who has experience coaching several different defensive schemes, should help the Browns secondary grow into a more effective unit in 2009. Of course, it is the first week of July as these words are being typed, which naturally reflects the optimist sentiment ingrained in all Browns fans during the weeks leading up to the season.

So, in saying that….the Browns are Super Bowl bound. Right?

I’m guessing the combination of fanciful summer dreams and the arrival of yet another new regime has gotten my hopes up for the future. However, I’m not sure that 2009 will be the culmination of these Super Bowl aspirations. In viewing the current roster, while realizing that Eric Mangini is merely in the infant stages of rebuilding the team in his own vision, I have to wonder what the future of the secondary holds for Cleveland.

Or, in other words…let’s skip ahead two seasons and envision that Eric Mangini is entering his third year as Browns head coach. Regardless of his on-field success during the first two years of his tenure, you have to imagine that the roster has experienced a wealth of turnover. Using the secondary as a prime example, which of the following potential 2009 players will still be on the roster in 2011?

Eric Wright
Brandon McDonald
Rod Hood
Corey Ivy
Hank Poteat
Coye Francies
Don Carey
Gerard Lawson
Abe Elam
Brodney Pool
Mike Adams
Nick Sorensen

The idealist in me can picture Wright, McDonald, Pool, Elam, Adams, Francies and Carey all surviving to become a vital part of the Browns’ defensive future. All these players, with the exception of Adams, bring youth, athleticism and untapped potential to the roster. However, in reality, is likely that only Wright, Elam and possibly Carey will be long-term, productive members of the Browns.

So in giving that precocious speculation, what is the likelihood of success for the group in 2009? The simple prediction is that the secondary spots will essentially be filled by a collection of stop gaps. The likes of McDonald, Pool, Hood and others are temporary fixes, until Mangini finds some younger, more dynamic talent via the draft.

Looking at Mangini’s tenure with the Jets, it is very likely that a top flight cornerback will be selected within the next two years. Much like the selection of Alex Mack reflected Mangini’s previous drafts, which netted the Jets D’Brickashaw Ferguson and Nick Mangold, look for our new general to seek out a Cleveland version of Darrelle Revis in the coming years.

If the Browns could add a true top-flight cornerback, then the play of Eric Wright, Brandon McDonald and others in the secondary could be elevated to levels not seen since the days of Dixon and Minnifield…or possibly, the days of Langham and Griffin. Until more help arrives, the 2009 version of the Browns’ defensive backs remains unsettled. Although there is some talent here, it is largely misplaced.

Heading into 2009, the likes of Eric Wright and Brandon McDonald now have two years of NFL experience under their belts. However, both of the Browns’ projected starting corners still have some growing to do. In the case of McDonald, his impressive 2007 play, when he filled in due to injuries, led many to believe that he was a future star at corner. However, thanks to the limited depth at the position in 2008 (thanks again, Phil), McDonald was badly exposed in man coverage.

However, McDonald showed some great toughness by rebounding from a string of bad games and a mid-season benching (albeit a brief one), and improved during the last several games of the season. McDonald brings great athleticism to the position and has grown into a sure tackler, in an almost Daylon McCutcheon-esque manner. McCutcheon…I mean McDonald…certainly needs to improve against more physical receivers in order to become a true #2 corner. Again, the arrival of a top-flight corner would help the position in the future, as McDonald could florish in a less demanding #3 role.

The same could be said of Eric Wright. Although Wright is currently the best option at the position, he is by no means a top corner. Of course, in terms o
f 2009, Wright has to again be counted on to cover the opposing team’s best receiver. Wright brings good size, playmaking ability and range to the position. However, Wright’s inate gambling instincts, which should be an attribute the turnover-minded Mangini will covet, can often get the third-year corner into trouble.

Wright seems to play at a level that is bigger than his current skill set can support. While his determination and confidence are exceptional, Wright has not reached the level of consistency that is required of such a corner. Hopefully, Mangini and Ryan can work to further develop Wright’s play. Until then, the best chance of Wright becoming a quality corner lies in the drafting of the mythical top flight corner. Basically, Wright could become an exceptional #2 corner and could contribute several game-changing plays throughout the course of a season.

The wild card of the secondary in 2009 is Rod Hood. Hood brings some good experience to the position, having started 30 games in Arizona over the past two seasons. Entering Cleveland, Hood instantly becomes the biggest corner on the roster, which could help in terms of run support. Hood has shown some big play ability in the past, specifically in 2007, and offers an upgrade over McDonald. However, in looking to the future of the position, Hood could very well be a one and done type of player in Cleveland. If Hood starts and plays consistently, he will likely sign elsewhere in 2010.

Speaking of one and done, Mangini has employed a depth-building strategy similar to the offseason work done on the offensive line and among the linebacking corps. To shore up depth, Mangini brought in the ageless Hank Poteat and well-traveled Corey Ivy. Of the two veterans, Ivy could contribute in 2009, both in dime packages and on special teams.

The fate of Poteat should be determined by how quickly Hood and the rookies assimilate into the new system during training camp. If no one steps up in camp, then Poteat’s history with Mangini suggests that he could get a look at a starting position. And yes, I am very afraid. After all, the last time most Browns fans thought about Hank Poteat was when Kelly Holcomb was torching him in the playoffs years ago.

The first draft of the Mangini era brings the likes of Don Carey and Coye Francies to Berea. Both Carey and Francies played at smaller colleges and both offer some good size and presumably, intelligence. Reports from OTA’s and minicamp suggest that Carey has impressed the coaching staff by quickly learning and applying the team’s playbook. Carey’s size (5-11, 192 lbs.), smarts and fluid motion make him an ideal candidate for the team’s future. However, considering the volume of players at the position, Carey and Francies could spend 2009 on the practice squad.

The arrival of Abe Elam at safety could be viewed solely as a reflection of Mangini’s desire to stock the roster with players familiar to his coaching style and system. However, Elam could finally bring the physical presence the team has lacked at the safety spot in recent years. While Elam is not an ideal deep coverage safety (Buffalo’s Lee Evans was sorry to see him go), he may help the Browns’ run defense and also offer a much-needed blitz option. Based on his familiarity with Mangini’s system, Elam could start the season strong and continue to improve as he gets his first real starting experience in the NFL.

The fulcrum of the secondary could very well be the play of Brodney Pool. Pool has been a mystery of sorts throughout his short career. He certainly brings athleticism to the position, but seems to lack awareness at times. The mental aspect of Pool’s play has to improve in order for the Browns’ secondary to become a cohesive unit. Watching Pool progress throughout training camp should be interesting to watch, especially after Ryan recently admitted some doubts regarding the personnel at the position, which includes little depth after the fiesty Mike Adams.

IDEALLY….
Mangini’s coaching experience, combined with a more aggressive Rob Ryan defense reduces the pressure that usually confronts the Browns’s secondary. Eric Wright’s development continues and Rod Hood helps to solidify the starting lineup. Brandon McDonald’s reduced role helps him channel his 2007 production, while Don Carey becomes the rookie surprise of the team. The safety position is bolstered by good health, as Abe Elam florishes as a starter and Brodney Pool becomes a serviceable option. Finally, Corey Ivy and Hank Poteat offer one final year of production before drawing social security checks.

BUT REALLY….
The Browns’ cornerbacks continue to struggle, as Wright continues to show that he is not a true #1 corner, McDonald continues to get picked on and we all realize why no other team signed Hood during the offseason. The rookie corners spend the year on the practice squad, at best, offering no help in 2009. While Abe Elam helps the run defense, the deep secondary is exposed throughout the year, as Brodney Pool never catches onto Mangini’s system. Corey Ivy suffers from a gait disorder, while Hank Poteat is found wandering around East Third, shirtless and confused.

While there is some potential found among the Browns’ defensive backs in 2009, their success will likely be determined by the play of the team’s defensive front seven. If Mangini and Ryan can truly implement more aggressive schemes, then the pressure on the secondary should be reduced, leaving them in a position to make some plays throughout the season. Yet, despite the talent in front of the secondary, the current collection of defensive backs is still a work in progress. The arrival of talent via the draft over the next few years will likely signal a better sense of improvement than the version we could see in 2009.

Hey Tony! Tony Grossi Answers Your Questions, Then Lets You Know How He Really Feels

Hey, Tony! Tony Grossi Answers Your Questions

I’m not sure how I can possibly top last week’s marathon mailbag – featuring two of the most grueling emails I’ve ever received. Honestly, it took me a while to recover. So much for a summer vacation. Between these mailbags and rumor mongering, I just don’t have much time for traditional reporting anymore. Luckily, the Browns organization hasn’t been handing much news to us newspaper folk lately. Hmmm…now I wonder if the season has been cancelled or something. I should call up some of my sources. Nevermind – let’s just run with it – the season has been cancelled…you heard it here first.

Hey, Tony: Do you anticipate the Browns having any special problems signing their top draft choices, seeing they have three second-rounders to sign? I can’t remember the Browns ever having this many choices in the second round, do you? — Greg Dineen, Middletown, Ohio

Hey, Greg: It should be interesting, considering the way coach Eric Mangini has used the rookies in the off-season. He bused them 10 hours to work his charity football camp in Hartford, Conn., and also assigned them to community appearances on almost every weekend during the team’s off-season program. This rookie class represents the first round of contract negotiations for Dawn Aponte, the Browns’ new chief negotiator. Her credentials are impressive.

Hey, Greg: Do you anticipate me not directly answering your question, but instead slamming Eric Mangini? Yes? Oh, good.

Hey, Tony: I’ve been searching for a couple months to learn when practice sessions start this year. I’d like to take my grandson to see one. I see only the 2008 schedule. — Joan McQuown, Moreland Hills.

Hey, Joan: The only dates the Browns have announced are their first practice open to the public August 1 and Family Day at Cleveland Browns Stadium on August 9.

Hey, Joan: Perhaps you should have begun your search by first buying a computer, then going online to find the necessary information. God, it’s so pathetic when people just wait for information to fall into their laps.

Hey, Tony: If you were the new head coach of the Browns and had only two seasons to put together a Super Bowl team for Cleveland, what would you do differently as coach right now? Who would be your starting QB if the first game was tomorrow? If you could choose one player from any team to join your players, who would it be? — Gary Zadai, Ocala, Fla.

Hey, Gary: I suppose I would have done everything possible to trade one of the quarterbacks, and it probably would have been Derek Anderson. That said, Brady Quinn would be the starting QB if the first game were tomorrow. If I could choose one player from any team? Let’s eliminate the quarterbacks (Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, etc.). It would probably be a player from the following group: Ed Reed, DeMarcus Ware, Julius Peppers, Troy Polamalu and Chris Johnson. Johnson, the Tennessee running back rookie sensation, actually received my MVP vote last season. I felt he transformed the Titans’ offense into a force.

Hey, Gary: My first move as new Browns head coach would be to assign Eric Mangini as the team’s beat writer. Then, I wouldn’t talk to him. See how he likes that.

Hey, Tony: I seem to be one of the few Browns fans who thinks Syndric Steptoe is a much better receiver than people give him credit for. His stats aren’t astronomical, but they are respectable for a guy down the depth chart, and I don’t recall him dropping too many passes. Do you know how many catchable balls he dropped, how that number stacks up against other receivers in a similar slot on the depth chart? What are your thoughts on him as a receiver? — Terry Allen, Washington, D.C.

Hey, Terry: I would agree with your very first statement. I don’t see Steptoe as a playmaker in the NFL. Frankly, I think he would have difficulty making most rosters.

Hey, Terry: I’m going to ignore your request for stats, because that would be a ton of work. Oh, and also, emailing about Syndric Steptoe confirms that you’re an idiot.

Hey, Tony: I have heard the rumors involving Brandon Marshall to Cleveland. I realize at this point a deal looks unlikely. But I think it could be a good option for the Browns. I realize the guy has some character issues, but it sounds like he may be had for 60 cents on the dollar because of his trade demand. You can’t really deny the guy has talent. As a Browns fan, one of my fears going into this season is that both of our quarterback options look horrible in the preseason and we can’t get any value for either in a trade. If we could ship one of them (probably D.A.) to Denver now in a deal for Marshall I would be all for it. I would be especially happy with the deal if we can keep Josh Cribbs out of it. I heard rumors prior to the draft that Denver was interested in one of our QBs. I think we would have to give Marshall a contract extension with some very strict language regarding off-field conduct to even consider the move. But I would be willing to give up a QB, one of the WRs we drafted and maybe even a second-round pick in 2010 to get Marshall, plus whatever filler is needed to make the salaries work. Having two receiving threats would be great. Maybe the competition would help cure Braylon of the dropsies. — Dan Laveen, Arizona

Hey, Dan: Even setting aside Marshall’s off-field issues, I believe you are grossly overrating him as a player. I know he has phenomenal physical skills, but at this point I would hesitate to trade either quarterback for him even-up. I just don’t want to get involved with another problem-child receiver.

Hey, Dan: Jesus, Dan. Take a breath. I stopped your reading your question a long time ago. I guess your question is about Brandon Marshall, so let me just say this…I hate all young NFL players. There you go.

Hey, Tony: Sorry to hear about Bernie Kosar’s problems. He brought great memories to Cleveland Browns fans, and I wish him well in the future. What was his total income from all his years playing in the NFL? — Kurt Mews, East Peoria, Illinois.

Hey, Kurt: I don’t have all of Kosar’s contract figures for his playing years. I do recall that he signed with Dallas for $1 million for half the season in 1993 after Bill Belichick released him in the middle of the year.

Hey, Kurt: What is with all you people asking me about stats and numbers? I don’t know Kosar’s total income…how about 800 billion dollars? Happy now? How about I just end all of this with another shot at Belichick? Jesus, I’m tired.